Attack Rolls

Attack rolls determine whether your attack hits a target. Roll d20, add modifiers, and compare to the target's Armor Class (AC).

How Attack Rolls Work

Formula: d20 + ability modifier + proficiency bonus (if proficient)

Roll the d20, add your modifiers, and compare to the target's Armor Class (AC). If your total equals or exceeds the AC, you hit!

Melee Weapon Attacks:

  • Use Strength modifier (usually)
  • Finesse weapons: Choose Strength OR Dexterity

Ranged Weapon Attacks:

  • Use Dexterity modifier
  • Thrown weapons: Use Strength (or Dex if finesse)

Spell Attacks:

Critical Hits and Misses

Natural 20 (Critical Hit):

  • Always hits, regardless of AC
  • Double all damage dice (not modifiers)
  • Example: 2d6+4 becomes 4d6+4

Natural 1 (Critical Miss):

  • Always misses, regardless of modifiers
  • No additional penalties by RAW
  • Some tables use fumble tables (house rule)

Critical Hit Math:

  • Roll damage dice twice (or double the dice rolled)
  • Add modifiers once
  • Add extra dice from features (Sneak Attack, Smite) and double those too

Attack Roll Modifiers

Always Added:

  • Ability modifier (Str, Dex, or spellcasting ability)
  • Proficiency bonus (if proficient with weapon/spell)

Situational Bonuses:

  • Magic weapon bonus (+1, +2, +3)
  • Bless spell: +1d4
  • Bardic Inspiration: +1d6/d8/d10/d12
  • Fighting Style (Archery): +2 to ranged attacks

Advantage/Disadvantage:

  • Roll 2d20, take higher (advantage) or lower (disadvantage)
  • Roughly equivalent to ±5
  • They cancel each other out

Common Mistakes

Common Mistake
Adding proficiency to damage (it's only for attack rolls)
Common Mistake
Forgetting proficiency bonus on spell attacks
Common Mistake
Using the wrong ability modifier for the weapon type
Common Mistake
Double-counting modifiers on critical hits

DM Tips

DM Tip
AC 15-17 is typical for mid-level monsters
DM Tip
High AC makes combat feel swingy
DM Tip
Critical hits should feel exciting - describe them!
DM Tip
Remember ranged attacks within 5 feet have disadvantage